Last updated March 20th, 2025
Product Reviews
Having a reliable ice maker is a must for RVers, especially while traveling through hotter regions of the country. With so many options on the market, you must consider factors like ice production capacity, storage, size, and durability. This guide reviews four of the best portable ice makers available, comparing their key features, pros, and cons. Whether you’re looking for a high-capacity model for large groups or a compact option for solo travelers, we’ve got you covered.
Portable Ice Maker Comparison Table
Let’s start with a quick side-by-side comparison of our top four picks.
| Model | Igloo Premium | NewAir AI-100BK | Luma Comfort | Magic Chef |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Image | ||||
| Price | $159.99 | $189.97 | $247 | $164.99 |
| Weight | 22.27 lbs | 24.3 lbs | 25.5 lbs | 17.8 lbs |
| Material | Stainless steel, plastic | Stainless steel, plastic | Stainless steel, BPA-free plastic | Stainless steel |
| Dimensions | 14.09 x 9.65 x 11.54 Inches | 11.75″D x 14.5″W x 15″H | 14.8″D x 11.3″W x 14.1″H | 19.99 x 9.50 x 12.90 Inches |
| Warranty | 1-year limited | 1-year | 1 year | 1-year |
| Ice Production | 33 lbs/day | 28 lbs/day | 28 lbs/day | 27 lbs/day |
| Ice Sizes | Small, large cylindrical ice cubes. | Small, medium, large | Not specified | Small, Large |
| Noise level | Ultra-quiet device | Low but not silent (as per Amazon reviews) | Low but not silent (as per Amazon reviews) | Little noisy, as per reviews on Walmart |
1. Igloo Premium Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker Machine: The Best Quick and Efficient Ice Maker
Price: $159.99
Features
- Fast Ice Production: Makes nine ice cubes in just 7 minutes, with a daily output of up to 33 pounds.
- Self-Cleaning Function: Automatically cleans the interior to prevent bacteria growth, making maintenance a breeze.
- LED-Lit Control Panel: Easily select small or large cube sizes and monitor water levels with indicator lights.
- Compact Design: Measuring just 14.09 x 9.65 x 11.54 Inches, it fits neatly on RV countertops without taking up space.
- Ice Storage: The roomy ice basket stores 33 lbs of ice for 24 hours.
Pros
- Convenient Features: The self-cleaning mode and LED control panel simplify operation and upkeep.
- Fast and Efficient: Makes ice quickly while still being energy-efficient.
- Ice Shapes: Makes small or large cylindrical ice cubes.
- Easy to Use: Users have reported that this ice maker is very easy to use.
Cons
- Frequent Refills: Requires frequent refills due to smaller size if you need to make ice in a large quantity.
- Cleaning Required: Despite the self-cleaning mode, you need to clean it the old-fashioned way.
2. NewAir Counter Top Ice Maker Machine (AI-100BK): Best Compact Ice Maker
Best Compact Ice Maker
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/20/2025 09:30 pm GMT
Price: $177.74
Features
- Three Ice Sizes: You can choose from small, medium, or large cubes to suit different drink types.
- Speedy Production: It makes a new batch of ice in just 10 minutes, yielding up to 28 pounds daily.
- Compact Footprint: At just 1.75″D x 14.5″ W x 15″H, it tucks away easily in RVs, boats, and small kitchens.
- Basket and Scoop: The ice maker comes with an ice basket and scoop, making it convenient to use. It also has certified BPA-free parts.
Pros
- Space-saving: One of the most compact models available, perfect for RVs with limited counter space.
- Recycling of Ice: If the ice cubes stored inside melt, the water drains back into the ice maker again for ice production.
- Versatile: Offers a choice of three ice cube sizes for different needs.
- Insulated Storage: You can store ice inside the maker due to its insulated design.
- User-Friendly: Simple button controls and indicator lights make operation intuitive.
Cons
- Small Ice Bin: The ice basket has a small 1.5-pound capacity, requiring frequent emptying.
- Expensive: Due to its premium features, it is costlier than other ice makers.
3. Luma Comfort Clear Ice Cube Maker Machine: Best Splurge
Best Splurge
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/20/2025 09:50 pm GMT
Price: $222
Features
- Crystal-Clear Ice: Produces restaurant-quality clear ice cubes that melt slowly and look great in drinks.
- High Output: Can crank out up to 28 pounds of ice per day, enough for even large get-togethers.
- Stainless Steel Construction: Durable stainless steel housing stands up well to frequent use and travel.
- Water Recycling: Melted ice drains back into the water reservoir to be frozen again, conserving water.
Pros
- Excellent Ice Quality: Makes crystal-clear, slow-melting ice cubes that enhance drink presentation.
- Efficient: Built-in water recycling system minimizes waste for more sustainable operation.
- Durable Build: Stainless steel exterior and commercial-grade components are made to last.
Cons
- High Cost: Significantly pricier than other portable ice makers.
- Heavy: At over 25 pounds, it may be too hefty for some RVers.
4. Magic Chef Countertop Ice Maker: Best Budget-friendly Pick With Great Performance
Best Budget-friendly Pick With Great Performance
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/20/2025 09:51 pm GMT
Price: $128.08
Features
- Compact Size: Measures a space-saving 19.99 x 9.50 x 12.90 inches, freeing up precious RV counter space.
- Two Ice Sizes: Gives you the option of small or large bullet-shaped ice cubes.
- Quick Operation: Produces nine ice cubes per cycle in as little as 7 minutes.
- Large Daily Output: Can make up to 27 pounds of ice per day.
Pros
- Great Value: Produces plenty of ice quickly at a very reasonable price point.
- Space-Efficient: Has one of the smallest footprints of any portable ice maker we’ve seen.
- Easy to Use: Simple electronic controls allow you to fill the reservoir, press a button, and go.
Cons
- Fast-melting Ice: The ice prepared by this machine is cloudy and melts faster compared to clear ice cubes.
- Small Storage Bin: The ice basket only holds about 1.5 pounds, so you’ll need to transfer the ice often.
- Noisy: According to some user reviews on Walmart, this machine makes a noticeable noise while making ice.
How We Chose the Best Portable Ice Makers for RVs
To determine our top picks, we evaluated and compared each model based on several key factors:
- Ice Production Capacity: The ice production capacity is important, especially for RVers who need to produce ice in large quantities. We looked for portable ice makers that could produce at least 25 pounds of ice per day to keep up with the demands of RV life. Models with higher daily outputs scored extra points.
- Size and Weight: Since RV countertop space is often limited, size and weight become the most crucial features to consider. We prioritized compact models with small footprints. We also factored in weight since a portable ice maker should be easy to move around as needed.
- Durability: An ice maker for RV use needs to withstand jostling and frequent relocation. We favored models with sturdy construction, ideally with stainless steel components.
- Ease of Use: A portable ice maker must be easy to use. We looked for ice makers with intuitive controls, easy-to-read indicator lights, and thoughtful features like self-cleaning modes and ice size options.
- Value: We considered each ice maker’s price in relation to its features, performance, and durability to determine which offered the best overall value for RVers.
Choosing the Right RV Ice Maker for Your Needs
With so many great options to choose from, the right RV ice maker for you will depend on your specific needs and preferences. Consider how much ice you realistically need each day, how much space you can dedicate to an ice maker, and what your budget looks like.
If you want the highest ice production and a self-cleaning feature for easier maintenance, the Igloo Premium Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker is an excellent all-around choice. For those with very limited space, the NewAir AI-100BK and Magic Chef 27-lb Portable Ice Maker offer very compact form factors. And if you’re willing to spend more for the best ice quality, the Luma Comfort Clear Ice Cube Maker produces top-notch clear ice.
Whichever model you choose, be sure to clean your ice maker regularly and keep an eye on the water level to keep it running smoothly. If you wish to make your camping experience more enjoyable and comfortable, check out the 15 RV upgrades that we recommend for your rig.
